The purpose behind diversion centers was to stop cycling people with mental illness through the criminal justice system instead of getting them treatment and other services. All Rights Reserved. Scott Stringer said he found a severe lack of coordination between the $250 million-a-year program and other city-funded mental health services. The city comptroller is also investigating. Community Access has long pressed for a system in which police are never involved when people are experiencing a breakdown, interacting only with trained clinicians and peers individuals with mental health issues and a history of encounters with cops. Opinion| $850 million in American federal tax dollars is "missing." Former New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio's wife, Chirlane McCray, can't seem to account for the mass sum of money, which was intended to go toward the city's Thrive program, designed to aid those with mental health issues. Over the next four years, Ms. McCray would transform herself into a mental health evangelist. Something happened that triggered the need for me to go, she said without elaborating. ThriveNYC has led to an expansion of mental health first aid training. Besides the ramped-up spending, a big part of Thrive has been Ms. McCrays advocacy. But the budget discrepancies illustrate the difficulty in tracking Thrive.. With Thrive, spending rose to $346 million in fiscal year 2018, according to an analysis by the City Council. And even some experienced in mental health services have been surprised at what the service does not offer. N.Y.C. Copyright 2023 RedState.com/Salem Media. Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox for free every day by signing up below. The data also showed almost 190,000 Narcan kits were handed out to hospital where opioid use is common, but there is no evidence of how many were used. All articles were originally published on freedomoutpost.com and belong to their respective authors. It is not every billionaire who can watch his dream project literally . The NYPD has long struggled to correct this disturbing history, providing specialized training to officers. Co-Response will deploy on these individuals and get them connected to the help they need doing so also helps them avoid the criminal justice system and unnecessary visits to the hospital ER.. An empty bedroom in the yet-to-open diversion center announced four years ago for The Bronx. The Center for Innovation through Data Intelligence (CIDI) supported ThriveNYC by creating a collection of maps to illustrate the location of mental health and substance use facilities in New York City. I do not have any idea where the billion went, said Garcia, the former Department of Sanitation commissioner and one of the mayors longest-serving senior officials, on Fox 5s Good Day New York.. EMTs, though, arent signing up in big numbers. In 2019, City Hall proposed a pilot program to have the teams also respond to mental health 911 calls in East Harlems 25th Precinct and the Bronxs 46th Precinct the two precincts tapped for diversion centers. (According to data provided by the city, surveys of about 10,000 callers to NYC-WELL since late 2016 found about 60 percent felt better after calling the number. ThriveNYC: A Roadmap for Mental Health for All first describes largely New York City (NYC)-specific data that identify the health, social, economic, and criminal justice impacts of mental illness and highlight the range of structural, institutional, and care system challenges that need to be fixed.8 Its revolutionary, Mr. de Blasio told CNNs Symone Sanders during a recent forum at Harvard University. Instead, just focus on creating solutions that will truly work. Meanwhile, the city dedicated $51 million to a similar operation in East Harlem that opened this past November. Whats more, due to a general opaqueness when it comes to the programs budget, ThriveNYC has apparently left that nearly $900 million unaccounted for. Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group, Top $76,000-a-year New Jersey boarding school admits 'more should have been done' to stop bullying of boy, 17, who took his own life after being falsely accused of rape, Regulators seize and sell First Republic Bank to JPMorgan in second-largest US bank failure, Jack Dorsey says Elon Musk is NOT the best person to run Twitter as he says it 'all went south' for the billionaire after he bought the tech giant for $44B, A musical climax! For two hours on Tuesday, a dozen city council members and the public advocate asked questions about ThriveNYC, First Lady Chirlane McCray's mental health initiative. The site said it had tried and failed to acquire a line-item budget from Thrive, and the two budget breakdowns it had seen showed wildly different numbers. More than $15 million has been budgeted over the last three years for the effort; none has been spent. SCOTUS Grants Review of Case That Will Gut the Federal Bureaucracy, Straight White Male Republican Identifies as Lesbian of Color, His Family Receives 'Violent Threats', AOC Bends the Knee to Her Democratic Party Overlords on a Senate Run, Fox's Bill Melugin Delivers Blow to the Leftist Narrative About Texas Shooter, Vivek Ramaswamy Debated Gender With Chuck Todd, and It Was Absolutely Bonkers, Outgoing Chicago Mayor Lightfoot Waxes Hypocritical at Texas Gov. While Garcia was not involved in ThriveNYC, she served as de Blasios Department of Sanitation chief for six years. City Hall detailed its plans to whack $1.3 billion from its spending plans Tuesday as the coronavirus pandemic threatens to capsize the Big Apple's finances with billions in lost tax revenues Are we there yet? But the police are still often the only ones available to respond quickly to calls, even to the mental health line. The same disturbing scenario has played out repeatedly: A friend or relative summons the police because their loved one is having a breakdown and, in some cases, threatening violence. Officials are also collecting survey data. But weve built the structure that can get us there.. If you would like to be part of our project as a collaborator, we invite you to submit your application. One, fromfrom City Hall, showed $594million in spending, but a second, from the Independent Budget Office, showed $816milion. Dr. Belkin said that while suicide rates are not the best measure, the Health Department has been looking at trends in suicide attempts, based on emergency room visits. But a closer look at geocoded maps and colorful bar graphs in the Data Dashboard reveals missing metrics for over two-thirds of the programs, no advancements for about half of the initiatives and a major decrease in services badly needed during the COVID-19 pandemic. Both City Hall and IBO suspect the Office of Management and Budget included fewer programs in the City Hall version, accounting for the difference. That sounds a bit suspicious to me. October 15, 2021 To no avail, government watchdogs, politicians, and the media have long asked for accountability in spending from the $1 billion budget of New York City First Lady Chirlane McCray's ThriveNYC, the program that was supposed to combat mental illness for New Yorkers. Redirect ThriveNYC funds to address serious mental illness Jason Hansman, from Mayor Eric Adam's office, next described existing services to help New Yorkers quickly connect with mental health help, including a new service, in addition to 311 and 911, called NYC Well. 16 NORTH STREET, EXETER, EX4 3QS TEL: 01392 255 838. Nearly half the city's prison population has been diagnosed with mental health problems, but first lady Chirlane McCray's $250 million-a-year "ThriveNYC" mental health initiative has no presence in the jails. This would all hinge on the judgment: Is this a mental health issue? The data comes from aPolitico report that shows those running the scheme have largely failed to measure its impact or keep track of spending. That first year, she began talking with Dr. Belkin. The spokesperson noted that the overall number of mental health 911 calls in the 46th Precinct has declined by 18% in the last two years, and by 1.6% in the 25th Precinct. 2023 All Rights Reserved, NYC is a trademark and service mark of the City of New York. 1948. Sometimes you feel like youre in a conversation and suddenly youre left out in terms of being part of a thoughtful planning process that involves input from impacted communities, she added. Not all of the programs in her plan were new. The program, ThriveNYC, has fallen far behind its goals and appears to be a massive failure for the city. On Friday, the NYC comptroller announced a "deep dive" into exactly what Thrive has accomplished and exactly where the exorbitant amount of taxpayer money has been spent. The money that's in the wrong hands is the $850 million dollars in ThriveNYC mental health funds that he placed in the hands of his wife, Chirlane McCray. Good Cop Honors Oath to Constitution: Stops Bad Cop Whos Tasing a Man for His Free Speech, Taking Sides: The Christian's Responsibility in Civic Affairs II, EgyptAir MS804 Flight Attendant posted Picture on Facebook of Plane crashing a year before She Died, Blue Angels Marine Pilot Capt. So far, she has not been able to get the mayor to take it. New Yorkers are sick and tired of their Marxist spin where their politburo can do no wrong. Filtering by: Report Type Press Releases Remove constraint Report Type: Press Releases It includes dozens of programs run by at least a dozen agencies and is aimed at helping New Yorker Great Expectations viewers slam BBC for CHANGING ending of the Dickens classic with furious literature fans branding the show 'an abomination', Texas husband who survived massacre reveals dying woman told him to throw himself out window to escape bullets 'because my children were already without their mom' - as FBI says it has NO leads on illegal migrant shooter, Tim Bachman dead at 71: Bachman-Turner Overdrive guitarist passes following complications with cancer three months after brotherRobbie, From being born a man to Queen of the Mountains: Trans cyclist romps to victory in elite in women's race - winning $35,000 in the process - sparking new anger at the sport's transgender rules, Don Lemon's ousting from CNN has caused 'ARGUMENTS' with his fianc Tim Malone - who warned the disgraced anchor to 'cool it down' on-air before he was unceremoniously sacked after 17 years at the network, What a pizza work! Four years later it sits empty. Last year, the 46th Precinct, where the empty diversion center sits, averaged more than 320 such 911 calls per month. They pledged to post this information online in the coming weeks. Officials initially promised a pilot program in three NYPD precincts would be up and running by February. She has also published poetry and worked in . At our age, members of the Class of '48 have an abundance of free timeand Joyce Van Denburgh Doty, MFA '50, made excellent use of it with a detailed response to the Share Your News form.. Perhaps invigorated by the oxygen she uses (though she never smoked, she presumes she inhaled others'), she goes beyond her own TV watching of both old black-and-white shows and modern news to . Last week, de Blasio rebranded ThriveNYC changing its name to the Mayor's Office of Community Mental Health. The phones at NYC-WELL ring constantly, 180,000 times in 2018, according to city data. At its inception in 2015, ThriveNYC was a seemingly unwieldy 54 initiative program. To bypass internet censorship, connect with us directly by enabling our notifications (using the red subscription bell in the bottom right corner) or by subscribing to our free daily newsletter. The idea: to create state-of-the-art diversion centers staffed by mental health experts where police could drop off people experiencing mental health crises instead of escorting them to hospital ERs or jail institutions ill-equipped to deal with their needs. . Anyone can read what you share. The call center, operated under city contract, took over the old Lower Manhattan offices of a city suicide hotline known as LifeNet, a service with calls that peaked at 105,000 in 2014. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Meanwhile de Blasio announced earlier this week that he is mothballing his failed Renewal school program after spending $773million. ThriveNYC will advance these principles through 54 powerful, targeted initiatives, representing an . Nearly 100 Democrats Introduce Bill to Block Trump's Travel Ban, Trump's executive order rejecting the US's refugee programme to be reversed, Candace Owens Shreds Democrats During House Committee Hearing: WATCH, Leader of the #Blexit movement - to leave the Democratic Party - blasts top Dems, Pelosi Blasts 'Queen Bee' AOC for Dragging Democrats to Radical Left, Speaker unloads of Democratic Party progressives during interview, AOC Turns on 'Divisive' Ex-Chief of Staff; Says He 'Targeted' Moderate Democrats, Ocasio-Cortez blames Saikrat Chakrabarti for tensions between Squad and top Dems, Abbott Crushes Democrats: Supreme Court Denies Request to Restore Pay after Walkout, Biden Claims Economic Success as U.S Enters Recession: 'We Are on the Right Path', DC Mayor Deploys National Guard: Illegal Immigration at 'Tipping Point' in Capital, Biden Agrees to Close Gaps in Border Wall as Migrant Crisis Hits DC, Alec Baldwin's Wife Complains 'Enemies' of Husband 'Seek to Destroy' Him, Concert Canceled after 'Woke' Mob Complained about White Performer's Dreadlocks, Bill Barr: 'Hunter Biden Investigation Warrants a Special Counsel', [RELATED] Democrats Pass Bill to Fund College for Illegal Immigrants with Taxpayer Money, Chris Pratt Drops the Hammer on Cancel Mob as Anti-Woke 'The Terminal List' Soars to Number 1, Joe Biden Confronted Over Child Molesting Claims At CSPAN LIVE Event, Police: Satan-Worshiping Schoolgirls Plotted to Kill 15 Students, Drink Their Blood, 5 Things to Know About the Democrats Rebuttal to Nunes Memo. Among other things, they wanted to know how the program spent close to $1 billion in four years, and how its leaders measure the program's success. Barzilay noted that the city balked at the unions request that participants in the program get a 12% bump in pay, offering 6% instead. They have good ideas, but the implementation is what they stumble on, said Steve Coe, the chief executive of Community Access, which provides housing and other services to the mentally ill. Thrives primary focus is on the other end of the spectrum: New Yorkers who have less serious and possibly undiagnosed mental health problems, a population that according to City Hall encompasses 1.7 million city residents. Thrive also is meant to focus on communities African Americans, Latinos, military veterans who are less likely to seek care for mental health problems. Recursos Humanos. McCray oversees the program. So far, almost all of the information on follow-up care comes from the limited cases in which a social worker and psychiatrist have been sent to visit the person. First Lady Chirlane McCray speaks about the Thrive NYC program and the future of mental . Recently , I posted here on some news about the wall being built along our southern border. First lady Chirlane McCray's ThriveNYC unveiled a splashy new website Monday purporting to show the $1.25 billion plan has "dramatically improved the landscape of mental health services in New. Once-Thriving City Nonprofit Sputters Under Mayor's Wife, Chirlane McCray 99 The chairwoman of the Mayor's Fund to Advance the City of New York, Chirlane McCray, has largely been missing in. That said, this center has provided valuable assistance to New Yorkers with behavioral health needs and will be able to ramp up both centers once in-person operations are able to fully function again.. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the icon to the right of the comment, and report it as spam. Another $51 million went to a similar facility in East Harlem that opened in November 2020 and where only 45 people have been brought in for help so far, costing $1.1 million per visit. . So, what are the right measures?. The site said it had tried and failed to acquire a line-item budget from Thrive, and the two budget breakdowns it had seen showed wildly different numbers. One of ThriveNYCs signature programs, the mental health hotline NYC Well, saw 6,500 fewer callers during the first three months of this year that includes the start of the pandemic than the last part of 2019. Later, she wondered aloud whether her work with men like Mr. Abreu would be enough. ThriveNYC, a Mental Health Initiative, Comes Under Scrutiny The program spearheaded by Chirlane McCray, wife of Mayor Bill de Blasio, has an annual budget of $250 million Chirlane McCray, shown. She and her husband have been touting it as a "re. Facing historic budget crisis, NYC Council members call for cuts to signature de Blasio program, ThriveNYC. The money that's in the wrong hands is the $850 million dollars in ThriveNYC mental health funds that he placed in the hands of his wife, Chirlane McCray. POLITICO filed a records request for the programs line-item budget in October 2018, but the city has twice requested an extension. Its part of a $103 million ThriveNYC program. According toDavid J Harris Jr.s website. Health Department employees now conduct the eight-hour classes daily at churches, schools and community centers. Critics said the findings prove Thrive is a complete waste of money. Both City Hall and IBO suspect the Office of Management and Budget included fewer programs in the City Hall version, accounting for the difference. For example, 29 hospitals had agreed to screen almost 78,000 new mothers for post-natal depression each year as part of the scheme. I dont know what the questions will be. One, fromCity Hall, showed $594million in spending, but a second, from the Independent Budget Office, showed $816milion. Of $1B Missing from NYC Mental Health Program Some Went to Unused Diversion Centers. But the Public Health Call Center would have a regular, permanent presence and a more expanded catch-all approach, according to the plan. This story has been shared 603,033 times. A report from Politico back in February gently sounded the alarm the piece almost apologetically mentioned that Thrive NYC was headed for a reset but calls for transparency have increased in the last week after Thrive was unable in late Februaryto tell City Council members how the money was being spent. There were concerns when the program was implemented at the end of 2018 that the Mayor and his wife lacked the proper focus when it came to dealing with mental health issues as a way to divert funds for the program to marketing and PR rather than resources and facilities. [What you need to know to start the day: Get New York Today in your inbox.]. In November, Susan Herman, director of ThriveNYC and a senior advisor to de Blasio, announced the administration had decided to put the 911 plan on pause. These diversion centers were part of de Blasios criminal justice reform plan to have police drop off people in mental health crises there instead of bringing them to hospital ERs or jail, which is what they have long done. Run by the mayors wife and closest adviser, Chirlane McCray, ThriveNYC sought to tackle issues like substance use,depressionand suicide. It is meant to target low-income individuals who are often priced out ofmental healthcare because those services are typically not covered byinsurance. One graph plots how the poorest neighborhoods have double the amount of psychiatric hospitalizations compared to wealthier sections of the city despite Thrives $220 million annual budget that focuses on helping the neediest New Yorkers. Meanwhile, deadly encounters between NYPD officers and people in emotional distress have led to 18 fatalities in the last five years driving demands to remove cops from the equation. Ms. McCray implores those she meets to take the course, which includes discussions and role playing. The Thrive program budgeted millions to create diversion centers, a place other than jail for officers to bring those experiencing a mental health crisis. In the three years it has been running, organizers at ThriveNYC have largely failed to keep records of the initiatives achievements and data that has been collected shows it lagging well behind targets. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Documentary tells inside story of the Baker Street robbery of 1971, and the claims it was a secret service operation to cover up a royal scandal, Republican party chairwoman warns 2024 presidential candidates need to address abortion 'head on' - and suggests Dems would allow terminations at nine months, 'A waste of licence payers' money!' ThriveNYC Share The Mayor's Office of Operations partners with the Deputy Mayor for Strategic Policy Initiatives and the First Lady's team on the implementation of ThriveNYC, the City's roadmap to create a mental health system that works for all New Yorkers. To date, only 16 EMTs have signed up, according to Barzilay. David Woodlock, president of the Institute for Community Living and a former top state health official, praised Ms. McCray for her courage in taking on mental health issues. Repeatedly presented by City Hall as a four-year $850 million plan, city officials now say $560 million will have been spent in that time. There is already a mental-health hotline, "800-NYCWELL," the cornerstone of former Mayor Bill de Blasio and First Lady Chirlane McCray's controversial ThriveNYC initiative, and a Poison Control hotline. The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline. Underdog mayoral candidate Loree Sutton has raked in $113,000 in donations just two months after launching her 2021 campaign -- from a colorful cast of contributors including Craigslist founder Craig Newmark. The IBO budget shows $816 million. But back home, the effort, now in its fourth year, has sputtered. The city invested heavily on mental health before the de Blasio administration: For example, the Health Department spent $243 million in the 2014 fiscal year on mental health contracts. But all it takes is one wrong thing to say or they see the uniform and the person gets set off and the next time its chaos on the scene.. Comptroller Scott Stringer announced Friday that he will be looking into a city program that has spent nearly $1 billion without any details. I like to be transparent. The mental health initiative, known as ThriveNYC, is crucial to Ms. McCrays potential as a future political candidate, and has become increasingly important to Mr. de Blasio as he toys with a possible 2020 presidential bid. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Take the case of Saheed Vassell, the bipolar man shot dead on the street in his Brooklyn neighborhood three years ago after police responded to 911 calls about a man with a possible gun that turned out to be a piece of pipe. (Hes kind of busy, she said.). Chirlane McCray, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasios wife, was entrusted in 2015 with running a new initiative in the city called ThriveNYC, a program that attempted to address issues of homelessness, substance use, depression andsuicide, all centered around mental health and with a price tag of $250 million per year in tax payer dollars. ThriveNYC hasnt provided data that shows its programs are working, even though it promised to do just that, the New York Daily News reported more than a year ago. I'm not sure anybody does.'. Borelli wrote to City Hall asking for Thrives performance over the last four years since the program was created in 2015 and for performance data. Normally, we could articulate how Thrive has failed us by anecdotal evidence or the umber of mentally ill on our streets, said Councilman Joe Borelli (R-Staten Island). The ballots will include the new ranked-choice system, where voters will be able to choose their top five candidates. Chirlane McCray, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasios wife, was entrusted in 2015 with running a new initiative in the city called ThriveNYC, a program that attempted to address issues of homelessness, substance use, depression andsuicide, all centered around mental health and with a price tag of $250 million per year in tax payer dollars. The #WasteOfTheDay is presented by the forensic auditors at OpenTheBooks.com. Roughly 10 percent of the Thrive budget, more than $30 million in the current fiscal year, goes to address serious mental illness, according to City Hall. The city has committed to spending more than $50 million in taxpayer dollars to renovate and operate the Bronx diversion center. First lady Chirlane McCrays ThriveNYC unveiled a splashy new website Monday purporting to show the $1.25 billion plan has dramatically improved the landscape of mental health services in New York City over the last five years.. In the fall of 2017, the city Department of Health and Mental Hygiene signed a contract to spend millions of taxpayer dollars to rehab a 14,000-square-foot former IRS office inside an anonymous beige Bronx building covered with graffiti. He receives regular visits from a psychiatrist and a peer counselor. Good Day New York co-hosts Rosanna Scotto and Lori Stokes questioned Garcia about the ThriveNYC funds amid a spate of violent hate crimes committed by people with apparent mental illness.