Quite how England never managed to win an international tournament with those three in midfield is beggar belief, but all three of them still enjoyed highly successful careers with their clubs. Stevie G is widely regarded as not only the best captain, but also the best player in Liverpool history. ", Who was better: Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard? pubeboy Additional comment actions Just another view though. Have we settled the debate today? Scholes' omission prompted some to suggest Keane had settled the age old, Scholes, Gerrard and Lampard debate, with fans taking to social media to voice their opinion. Besides, it's a conversation that pulls in some of the biggest fanbases across the land with each player holding legendary status at Manchester United, Liverpool and Chelsea respectively. Asked whether there were any. Most Manchester United fans would argue Scholes was better, while Liverpool fans would say the same about Gerrard. That Arsene Wengers legendary Arsenal sides made special plans to stop Scholes prior to matches against United says everything about how dangerous and effective the midfielder was. If were only counting major trophies, he wins this round by a country mile. The average rating across Scholes' three ICON cards comes to 89, which is enough to oust Gerrard on 88.6 and Lampard with 88. . However, with Guardiola's loyalties lying with Manchester City, there was always going to be the opportunity for him to give an honest and open answer on the debate as opposed to sitting on the fence as is so often the case. He is currently the 5th highest goal scorer in Premier League history, with 177 goals in total. Description () - Paul Scholes playing for Manchester United F.C.3. Premier League Champion 11; 1995/96: 1996/97: 1998/99: 1999/00: 2000/01: 2002/03: 2006/07: 2007/08: 2008/09: 2010/11: 2012/13: He wins 3 of the 6 criteria, with Lampard in second place with 2, and Gerrard in third place with 1. As per the reasons Ive stated previously, there are unfortunately no reliable stats available for us to use as a basis for this category. ", Scholes broke his silence on the debate involving himself, Gerrard and Lampard back in May by saying he is "sick to death of hearing about this.". Official: Aston University A100 2023 Entry Applicant and Offer Holder thread, 2023 Oxbridge Anthropology Postgraduate Application. We'll openly admitted that the data is hard to come by in this department, but Transfermarkt attributes 23 international assists to Gerrard, which is more than the 12 and 10 put on Lampard and Scholes' names. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Its common knowledge that younger players have less wear and tear and are thus able to output a much high work rate on the pitch. What's more, it's not really that close. After spending 20 years playing for Manchester United, Scholes retired from professional football in 2013, at 38 years of age. But none of that really matters does it? "It's probably more towards Toni Kroos, as a passer and more of a controlling player. Answer: Steven Gerrard Admittedly, there's no universally-agreed way to decide which accolades should count here, but Gerrard takes the win by our calculations with at least 50 individual. All in all, it's about the umpteen-millionth time that an ex-pro has confessed their admiration for Scholes with Guardiola joining the likes of Zinedine Zidane and Xavi to eulogise about him. Similar experiments have been carried out between Juventus superstar Cristiano Ronaldo and legendary Brazilian Ronaldo. Steven Gerrard vs Paul Scholes: Thierry Henry gave his opinion License () - CC BY-SA 3.02. So the next time that Scholes is slandered and lambasted in the latest iteration of the debate with Gerrard and Lampard on social media, just remember the expression on Guardiola's face. As well as being named in the Euro 2012 Team of the Tournament, Gerrard has scored more than his rivals at the World Cup and European Championships with a total of four goals on the big stage. Henry is considered by many as the greatest player of the Premier League era, but even he was in awe of Scholes ability. Both Gerrard and Lampard received their most votes in the same year (2005). Look and decide which of these players is better.: 1) Jeremy Blake - The Emperor's Army; 2) Konrad OldMoney - The Nexus RiddimImages (): 1) Paul Scholes1. When you look into the similarities between these three individuals, based on their playing careers, its easy to see why the comparisons are so prevalent. End of. To make sure you never miss out on your favourite NEW stories, we're happy to send you some reminders, Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications, .css-1diosym{color:black;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-1diosym{color:#fff;}}Published0:04,03 June 2020 BST.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-7su1ft{color:#72B97D;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}}| Last updated0:05,03 June 2020 BST. steven gerrard vs paul scholes [individual awards/achievements] 1x uefa club footballer of the year 8x pfa pl team of the year 3x fifa fifpro world xi 3x uefa team of the year 1x uefa cl final man of the match 6x pl player of the month 2x fa england player of the year 1x ballon d'or bronze award 4x liverpool player of the season 4x liverpool top goal scorer 1x uefa euro team of the tournament . EDITORIAL USE ONLY. Those aspects, to name a few, are first touch, aggression, composure, vision, defensive and offensive awareness and defensive and offensive positioning. Matches, Goals, Assists, Yellow Cards, Red Cards, Playing Time, Awards, Trophy \u0026 More. Keane played alongside Paul Scholes for many years at Old Trafford (Image: GETTY) Champions League's official Twitter account ran a poll asking fans who was the greatest back in 2018. Both games ended up being 3-3, with Liverpool winning on both on penalties in both occasions, and Gerrard scoring vey important goals in both matches. Share your most controversial football opinions! During a fan Q&A on Twitter in 2017, Kroos had no hesitation in naming Scholes ahead of fellow Premier League legends Gerrard and Lampard in the long-running debate. However, I feel that there has to be a winner in each category. The Student Room and The Uni Guide are both part of The Student Room Group. Where to watch football in chester other than pubs, Broadcasting talent deserts BBC after they cancel Lineker, New Adventure. "I'm sick to death of hearing about this, to be honest. While all three possessed great experience and game intelligence in their later years, Scholes was undoubtedly, the one that managed to stay effective for the longest. Having watched him in his prime, all I remember is this guy outscoring strikers left, right and centre from the midfield. Pep Guardiola is pretty well placed to answer the Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard debate. I have to go with Paul Scholes, and I love Stevie G. Paul Scholes was just ahead in his head. However, arguably better than the actual content of his answer was the look on Guardiola's face as he revealed his admiration for Scholes, going all giddy as though he was a fanboy in the stands. Is Messi now the undisputed greatest of all time? Paul Scholes, Paul Scholes.. And SPORTbible has now decided to use Futhead to do a side-by-side comparison of Scholes and Gerrard's in-game stats in FIFA 20. When we use these stats alone as a basis for comparison, Lampard clearly wins. Argue with the captain of the treble winners lol. Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard: 19 footballers who Just as an aside note, I will only be considering their playing careers within the English Premier League. Steven Gerrard vs Ryan Giggs | BigFooty Forum During an appearance on Sky Sports Monday Night Football in 2019, however, Henry caused a stir on social media with his opinion on the Scholes vs Gerrard debate. He went on to play in Los Angeles for a single season before eventually retiring from professional football in 2016. Yet another generational talent that is widely considered to be the best player in the history of his club. But in truth, he could do it all; defend, attack, the whole deal. No. Therefore, this category has to go to Paul Scholes. Hi there! Subsequently, all three were understandably also moved deeper and deeper towards the end of their careers. "Scholes was better than Gerrard or Lampard" - Reddit Career Comparison. People who have no idea how absolutely ridiculous a player Robson was. Players and managers praise Trent Alexander-Arnold, Steven Gerrard's insane pass vs Arsenal in 2002, Thread names Mo Salah Premier League's best attacker. The Cambridge College Hurt/Heal Game [part 2], The Russell Group hurt/heal game (Part 5). Who was the Best Midfielder Between Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard? ", One Twitter user, who just so happened to be a Liverpool fan, said: "Roy Keane leaving out Paul Scholes in his greatest Premier League team ends the Gerrard Scholes Lampard debate. However, Wayne Rooney scored the best goal he's ever seen live: *that* overhead kick against Manchester City at Old Trafford. Even Lampard's second highest assists tally in a Premier League campaign - 14 during 2009/10 - is enough to eclipse his former England colleagues. Seeing as all three of these players started their careers in the early to mid-90s, comparing them from a statistical point of view, with the data available, doesnt yield a concrete outcome. To make sure you never miss out on your favourite NEW stories, we're happy to send you some reminders, Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications, .css-1diosym{color:black;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-1diosym{color:#fff;}}Published17:07,27 November 2020 GMT.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}@media (prefers-color-scheme:dark){.css-7su1ft{color:#72B97D;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-7su1ft{color:#666666;}}| Last updated17:17,27 November 2020 GMT. Biggest capitulation in modern day sports? Something went wrong, please try again later. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Therefore, this answer will contain a tad bit of subjectivity. Ultimately, its all down to personal opinion. His ball striking technique, excellent ball control and tireless work rate made a him a real threat in front of goal. In Scholes second last season with Manchester United, at 38 years of age, he was able to achieve a 92% pass completion rate, while only losing possession, on average, once every 154 minutes. No disrespect to Liverpool, but Gerrard was never surrounded by the caliber of players that the other two had. Therefore, its very difficult to assess what his highest ranking is. (edited 9 years ago) 1 So much so, that the fact that these players failed to win any major honors, will forever remain as a question of what could have been. Published Nov 16, 2020. Safe to say 2005 was a good year for English Football. https://www.premierleague.com/players/800/Frank-Lampard/stats?co=1&se=18, https://www.premierleague.com/players/1575/Steven-Gerrard/stats?co=1&se=22, https://www.premierleague.com/players/336/Paul-Scholes/stats?co=1&se=21, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Lampard, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Gerrard, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Scholes, https://eplindex.com/13635/paul-scholes-midfield-maestro.html, https://www.infogol.net/en/player/frank-lampard/2950, https://www.infogol.net/en/player/steven-gerrard/2865, https://eplindex.com/50755/steven-gerrard-frank-lampard-13-14-stats-comparison.html, https://www.premierleague.com/stats/clarification. If Im being completely honest, before even beginning any research for this category, I was convinced that Frank Lampard would be head and shoulders above the other two in terms of personal achievements. The fallout continued even after Scholes' international retirement in 2004, with Gerrard and Lampard failing to work together in a midfielder two for the Three Lions. Who's the best? This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. So, you can be sure that when the question is cast into the spotlight that the corresponding comments section will see hundreds of rivals fans trying to defend their own club legend. A master at keeping possession and controlling the tempo of the game. Now onto individual achievements. Football - Manchester United v Bolton Wanderers Barclays Premier League - Old Trafford - 14/1/12, Manchester United's Paul Scholes celebrates scoring his sides first goal, Mandatory Credit: Action Images / Jason Cairnduff. Paul Scholes VS Steven Gerrard. A Scholes defender tweeted: "Roy Keane leaving out Scholes will give all the Gerrard Lampard were better lot ammunition. Author () - 4. Naturally, as players age, they lose this ability. Gerrard never in top 3, but very close Scholes nowhere near top 3 Highest Ballon D'or Finish Lampard 2nd - one time Gerrard 3rd - one time Scholes nowhere near top 3 Premier League Team of the Year Appearances Gerrard 8 Lampard 5 Scholes 2 Premier League Player of the Month Awards Gerrard 6 Lampard 4 Scholes 4 Author () - Austin Osuide4. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. By Rob Swan. The Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard debate has raged for over 20 years, with fans split not just on who the greatest midfielder of them all was but also which combination of the two performed better for England. Lampard isn't far behind with 44 gongs and Scholes is way off the mark with only 12 awards being accounted for. Im Tinashe Chipako, the creator and author of the blog posts on footballiconic.com. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Lampard barely has half of that in second place with 14 accolades and Gerrard brings up the rear with nine trophies of which, infamously, the Premier League crown isn't one. . Football fans have never been able to agree on the answer, but an intervention from Roy Keane on Monday Night Football could have settled the argument once and for all. His overall understanding of the game allowed him to dictate the pace of each match in a way that is still yet to be matched in the Premier League. SPORTbible has previously used the same experiment to compare Barcelona captain Lionel Messi with Argentine icon Diego Maradona. Gerrard vs Scholes - The Student Room While these numbers are obviously elite, Scholes was just on another level in this department. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Seeing as these players were all midfielders and were given several tasks and responsibilities, I wanted to leave no stone unturned and be as objective as possible. The final criteria is understandably more subjective than the other two. Zinedine Zidane was his footballing idol growing up (a maestro capable of turning football into art) although Lionel Messi has brought him an equal amount of joy since first watching the Argentine play in 2005. As previously stated, this is a measure of who was able to adapt better over the course of their career. Gerrard vs Lampard vs Scholes - VERY INTERESTING READ The Irishman appeared on Sky Sports' flagship show for Manchester United's home match against Brentford on Monday night, where he was asked to name his ultimate Red Devils XI of the Premier League era. Likewise, Gerrards time in Los Angeles will not be considered. Source () - Cropped and lightened version of the file uploaded to Flickr with the name scholsey5. Gerrard in his prime was a true box to box midfielder, capable of being at either end of the pitch at a moment notice and contributing greatly wherever he was. It's a debate that has raged for well over two decades: Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard or Frank Lampard? All three played football professionally for roughly two decades, so this is essentially an assessment on how effective they were able to remain, despite the natural evolution of the game over time. And, right off the bat, its worth noting that although they share many similarities, all three of these players had different responsibilities within their respective teams, this makes it difficult to compare them. Paul Scholes or Steven Gerrard: Who was the better footballer? Between the mid 90s to roughly the early 2010s, England was blessed with a vast array of incredibly talented football players in virtually every position. Im a casual football player and hardcore fan. Today, however, we are here to discuss three particular players who were part of this golden generation and who are frequently compared to one another. File ( ) - Steven Gerrard 2018.jpg In a wide-ranging conversation, Ferdinand just couldn't resist putting the age-old question to one of the greatest managers of all time, and his reaction was so good that it's gone viral months after he initially said it. A childhood obsession for all things football developed into a career writing about the beautiful game. However, back in November, we looked at the response from 19 different footballers (current and former) who answered the Scholes vs Gerrard vs Lampard debate. The other midfielder (pause) is Steven Gerrard, in 18th place, with 120 goals. Every time we were playing them, we needed to find a way to stop him. In any case, this is a debate for another day. Each player is awarded one point if they win a particular stat category, while a tie awards each footballer a 0.5 score. 3. Honours & Awards. Gerrard had the ability to not only be a vocal presence on the field, but also to truly lead by example. Result: Scholes on 13 points and Gerrard on 16 points. To be more specific, they will be compared based on their in-game statistics, technical ability, leadership and influence, individual awards and team-based awards. Paul Scholes VS Steven Gerrard. The highest scoring midfielder in Premier League history averaged a goal every 3.37 games across his entire career. Rob is editor of GiveMeSport, with over 15 years experience covering sport in various capacities since graduating from university with a degree in journalism. I'm currently doing applications for A-Levels and don't know what subjects to choose. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. However, I'm not sure any of them are the greatest English midfielder of all time. I think Stevie G comes really close to him but Paul Scholes would have to win., After Carragher gave him some stick for picking Scholes over his mate Gerrard, Henry held his hands up and said: Im just saying! To give you an idea of how prolific this man was throughout his career. Gerrard not only has the most Ballon d'Or nominates with six, but his total number of votes (220) defeats Lampard's tally of 169 and Scholes famously never received a single vote from five nominations. Both Lampard and Scholes have been appointed as captains for Chelsea and United, in the past. I think he had everything but the other two, come on, Frank and Steven Gerrard changed this Paul Scholes is my favourite.". You think Paul Scholes was better than Steven Gerrard? former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher responded, sounding a little puzzled. Gerrard clear of all. Sven-Goran Eriksson was unable to fit all three into the same side, often resulting in criticism from supporters when one of them was left out. However, they also gain experience and in game intelligence, this allows them to conserve their energy for when it is needed and still remain effective. This was actually his second retirement, but thats a story for another day. Cambridge - MPhil Advanced Computer Science - Entry 2021, Official University of the Arts London 2023 Applicants Thread, Official Cambridge Postgraduate Applicants 2023 Thread, Official Oxford 2023 Postgraduate Applicants Thread, A-level English Literature Study Group 2022-2023. Unfortunately, as stated on the Premier League website, the majority of these stats were only recorded comprehensively starting from 2006 onwards. There are further aspects that cant really be recorded as stats that also need to be considered in this category as well. Football fans reckon Roy Keane has settled the age old Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard or Paul Scholes debate. The Chelsea legend leads the way here by teeing up 102 goals during his time in England's top division, edging out Gerrard's record of 92 and completely overwhelming Scholes' tally of 55. "He's different to me because he was quicker than me, he can beat a man, but I see certain traits in him, like controlling a game. Alas, we will never know how that couldve turned out. However, this was almost always on a temporary basis. It's not the first time Scholes, Lampard and Gerrard have been the subject of fierce debate. Despite the fact that Gerrards highest ranking is 3rd, Lampard wins this round. ", Topics:.css-wpf514{color:#72B97D;}Frank Lampard, Paul Scholes, Los Blancos, Football News, Football, Toni Kroos, Steven Gerrard, Real Madrid, La Liga, Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney confirm they are serious about signing Gareth Bale for Wrexham, Real Madrid in pursuit of Man Utd's Alejandro Garnacho with deal deemed 'very manageable', Perfect for Liverpool - Robbie Fowler urges Jurgen Klopp told to sign Newcastle's Joelinton, Jordan Pickford hilariously celebrates penalty save to deny James Maddison, fans are all saying the same thing, Sky Sports have spoken to Martin Tyler over Heung-Min Son comment he made in Liverpool vs Spurs commentary, BREAKING: Graeme Souness leaves Sky Sports after 15 years as a pundit, Virgil van Dijk had his left ankle and entire reputation shattered by Ivan Perisic's run, Gerrard, Scholes and Lampard have been frequently compared by fans, Scholes, 45, has previously spoken with high admiration for Kroos and said he sees a bit of himself in the Germany captain, Steven Gerrard was 'on another planet' to Paul Scholes and Frank Lampard, Sven Goran Eriksson Settles Steven Gerrard, Frank Lampard Or Paul Scholes Debate, Pep Guardiola picks Paul Scholes in the classic 'Gerrard, Lampard or Scholes' debate, Toni Kroos Has His Say On The Gerrard, Scholes, Lampard Debate.